Monday, January 26, 2009

The best way to make a difference?

Between exams, confusion over the start of the semester and, finally, an ill-timed "wind chill" day, I've only been in a few times this semester. Still, I've reached a dilemma -- how can I best use my time at Ypsi High to positively influence my students? Do I attempt to inspire or enrich as many students as possible by dividing my attentions over the whole class, or do I focus on bringing a small, struggling subset up to par? How can I balance these priorities?

I initially gave presentations on technical topics, trying to bridge the gap between contrived textbook examples and the students' or my own experiences. This can lead to some nice eureka moments ("You mean somebody actually uses this stuff?", or, "Wow, that's cool", sneakily making math cool by association), at least in the classes of older students, but it sometimes spreads thin on a class of 25 freshmen, over half of whom are failing basic algebra. It begs the question -- is my time better spent coming up with entertaining uses of math designed to appeal to a broad audience, but having little measurable effect, or else in concentrating on those few struggling students who would most benefit from extra attention?

This dilemma became acute in the leadup to semester exams. After observing so many students struggling with solving basic algebraic equations for lines, slopes and intercepts, presenting some bit of engineering entertainment seemed... irrelevant. Instead, with George's help I picked out a few borderline students in each class, kids on the knife-edge of passage or failure, that I hoped could make the leap with some extra time in a small group. We looked for a profile of students struggling to pass but still caring enough to put in an effort -- the kind of student who would benefit from a couple of days of tutoring, one-on-one or in a small group -- and I cleared my schedule to come in the Thursday and Friday before exams. We ended up with four students, three in a group and one by himself spread over two hours, and without the distractions of twenty other kids I walked them through as much material as we could manage, guided only by the areas that they found most confusing. While the group of three only included one student who fit both criteria -- one girl was doing well enough to pass (though struggling with recent material), and another just didn't want to be left out of going with her friends -- I figured I could handle three as well as one.

Despite the weather holiday that Friday depriving me of half my teaching time, one of my borderline students passed (I have yet to hear the result from the other). A small victory, to be sure, but a victory nevertheless. Still, while the imminent exam made this victory clear, it's less clear how effective my prior efforts were. Will someone who enjoyed one of my science talks and passed last semester discover a subject they might once have thought dull and dry? Where is the balance between lifting up the struggling students and helping the gifted ones soar?

For now, I'll enjoy my small victory. But next semester we return to square one, teaching those students who failed Algebra I and must repeat the course. I hope a few of them will soar, too.

Wednesday, November 12, 2008

Thrown to the Lions

The Situation:

Last Friday, I taught a class... by myself. Two classes, actually. But first things first...

Last Friday, George had a writing workshop to attend during 3rd and 4th hour. He has missed a lot of classes lately for various planning initiatives, meetings, etc., so losing yet another day of curriculum time while a substitute babysat was less than ideal. My impression of substitutes is that if a sub can keep the students from committing any prosecutable offenses, you chalk it up as a success. Get them to do a worksheet to boot? Bonus. Like I said, not ideal.

So, I said, "I have an idea! The kids know me, I've been in for several weeks now, why don't I come in, observe during 1st and 2nd hour, and try to teach the lesson myself 3rd and 4th hour?" George looked at me, must have realized I was serious, and decided to give me just enough rope to hang myself with. Mission accomplished. Oh, the naivete of youth.

The Plan:

The lesson for stats did, in fact, revolve around a worksheet. The algebra lesson was to create equations out of word problems and also to start introducing "units", like miles per gallon, miles per hour, feet per second, etc.

I prepared a powerpoint talk for algebra explaining how an internal combustion engine works (in simple terms with lots of pictures and movies), and contrasting these with electric cars, which can be hybrids (parallel or series, although I didn't use those terms), or fully electric plug-ins. The tie-in was at the end to talk about finding a break-even point in buying an expensive high-mpg hybrid versus a cheaper low-mpg regular car.

Stats Grade: B


Stats was a little rocky, but okay. It was really challenging being both the good cop and the bad cop though! Normally, I let George worry about maintaining overall classroom discipline from the front while I float, basically putting out fires as individual students fall behind, get stuck, or need a swift (verbal) kick in the butt to get to work and stop daydreaming. I can be everyone's buddy, and I only have to deal with a couple people at a time. Cupcake city.

Without George in front, the well-oiled machine's wheels start to wobble. His absence, even after I told them I'd be teaching today, was a change of routine, and as the new authority figure, they decided to test my limits. Worse, since I'm usually the good cop, I think they expected to get away with it. Not without a fight! We did the worksheet in stages: assign a few problems, walk around and answer questions, go over the problems on the projector, assign the next few, repeat.

The volume in the classroom was substantially louder than during a Lancaster class. Rather than shout for quiet repeatedly, which I feel like is a great way to erode your own authority and turn a class against you, I concentrated on trying to get the few main noise radiation sources silenced. This meant breaking up a few of the larger "working groups" and sending kids back to their seats to work in pairs. One kid in particular, M, didn't want to move back after I asked him. Here's the exchange, roughly:

Me: M, why don't you and R head back to your seats. I'll be right over to help you.
M: No, we're fine, I'm working over here.
Me: No, sorry, it wasn't optional. Go back to your seat. I don't want groups larger than three (they were five).
M: (some further response along the lines of "No I'm doing okay I'm staying here", as he's copying the answers from the kid next to him)
Me: M! Did I stutter? Go back to your seat!
M: :::suddenly hurt look::: Okay, I'm going (as he continues to copy without moving)
Me: No, you're not. Move.
M: I'm going, I'm going (hasn't scooted his seat back yet, or picked up his pencil or paper)

At this point I made a grab to take his paper and walk it over, assuming he'd follow, back to his seat. I was slow, didn't get it, and a) made myself look foolish and b) failed to accomplish forcing him to move, so I settled for standing and waiting there for the next several seconds while he gathered up his stuff and started moving. After this, thing seemed to settle down a bit, although one girl kept asking me if she could call her coach (sport unknown) to tell them she wouldn't be at practice, and another if she could take a nap during class because she had, like, the most important swim meet ever in a couple of hours and needed to rest. I rather doubt Lancaster would have had these questions asked. Alas, I'm a softie, and I let them. Doing it again, I wouldn't have ("Would Mr. Lancaster let you? No, I don't think he would.")

Stats Areas for Improvement

1) Phrase requests as requests, and demands as demands. "Why don't you" do x suggests that you can be dissuaded. If it's not an option, don't phrase it like it is. Even if a student knows what you really meant, they can use this as a "loophole" to stall. Choose your words so the options are a) obedience or b) flagrant disobedience. Getting students in the habit of obeying, especially when you make reasonable demands, makes it more likely they will continue to do so. If a student really chooses option (b), you've got bigger problems.

2) Less arguing! Arguing enhances the illusion that what you've asked is up for discussion. Your authority in front of the class is as much force of personality as your ability to impose some sort of disciplinary retribution. Arguing also builds ill will between you and the student (M wouldn't talk to me the rest of the hour).

3) Directions with choices are more palatable than directions without. In retrospect, I think I would have said, "M, I want you and R to work separately from S and B" and let them choose to take the nearest desks, rather than go back across the classroom to their own desks. Leaving a little choice allows the student to feel like they've got some say and "save face" (important to prevent resentment) while still doing what you want.

4) Tone is important. You can take a confrontational , angry tone, or you can speak calmly, quietly even, and go for the "I don't need to raise my voice because it's inconceivable you would not do what I ask" effect. I suspect this last takes years of practice (and some knowledge of what to do if the inconceivable, uh, conceives), but I think the voice-raising is something that, like a good spice, is used sparingly. George rarely raises his voice, but you notice when he does.

Algebra Grade: C-

If I had a few bumps with stats, full of college-bound seniors and juniors, I knew there was turbulence ahead with the freshman algebra class. Several of the class inexplicably didn't recognize me and thought I was just a sub, which I found odd, since I've been there almost a dozen times now. Nevertheless, I got off to a pretty good start here. The car theme caught the class' attention as I had hoped, and I got some pretty good class involvement as I showed the pictures and videos explaining how pistons work and then transitioned to the electric cars. This part went OK too, until I got to the end with the two cars and started to try to work in the lesson.

I swear, when I got to the slide with the picture of the Prius and Focus with their price and mileage, and started talking about setting up an equation, it was like a switch went off. Talking, no attention at all, and difficult to get class involvement in either forming or solving the equations for finding a break-even. First I had the class calculate a $/yr for the car from its mileage, taking an average 12000 mi/yr and a class-decided $3/gallon. Even then, calculating the break-even was like pulling teeth, and I had other distractions too.

T asked to go to the bathroom. I let him, and 20 minutes later I had to send the sub out to search for him in the halls. (There was still a sub present, since George was out; I just took care of trying to teach -- though the sub actually helped maintain the discipline somewhat) He found T hanging out in the cafeteria, chatting with friends. Then, T and two girls in the back, Ty and ?, were talking incessantly and loudly, at some points standing up to gesture and argue with each other while I was speaking. They'd been behaving this way all hour, despite my attempts at silencing them, and finally I got fed up with it and sent the three of them to sit out in the hall. Not ideal, but I was a bit frustrated, could you tell?

Meanwhile, the lesson was going poorly, partly because the idea of getting dollars per year out of three distinct pieces of information was a little too advanced, partly because the numbers were big ($15000, $1000/yr, etc. -- frightening due to sheer number of zeros at the end for the algebra Paduans), partly because I was going slow to try to keep the struggling portion of the class and thus losing the interest of the brightest ones who were most likely to respond to questions, thus causing me to wait longer for answers, go slower, vicious cycle, etc.

Algebra Areas for Improvement

1) Start from the simplest example and move to the most complex. Not the other way around. This should be intuitively obvious, but sometimes you can delude yourself into thinking, "Wait, no, this other slightly harder example is so much cooler, we can go over that in a lot of detail, and then those other simple boring examples will be much easier and can be done quickly." This is so wrong it's frightening. If I, a grad student with degrees in physics and engineering, think a problem is "slightly harder but cooler", a ninth grader is going to think it's unintelligible and hey, it's math, it's not cool either way. Perspective is important.

2) Excessive wait time is just as annoying for kids now as it was when I was in school. Wait time is when the teacher asks a question and then waits ... and waits ... and waits for a painfully long time while crickets chirp in the silence and no one either knows the answer or wants to answer. This is annoying for the bright kids who know the answer but don't want to raise their hand for the twelfth time because it's not cool, and it's also irritating for the kids who don't get it and just want you to say the answer and see if they can figure it out while trailing behind. Involving students is important, but all good things in moderation. George often zips through his lessons, and I think this has to be one of the reasons he does it -- the bright students don't get bored, and you can help the struggling students with questions individually in the time you've saved.

3) Know what the classroom rules are and what the discipline ladder is. Are hats allowed? Phones? Food / drinks? Is step one after a verbal warning to take away participation points? Or is it having to sit by yourself at the front of the room? At what point do you send the student to the principal's office? I feel like the great disadvantage of a substitute is their feeling of powerlessness to enforce any discipline on the students. Sending the students out in the hall was not ideal, nor was it what Mr. Lancaster would have done, but lacking that exact knowledge I just improvised to try to minimize distractions to the rest of the class. In retrospect, I would have first told the students they were losing some (and then all) of their participation grade for the day, then moved them to separate seats, then considered further steps if necessary (unlikely).

4) Beware of getting your students too worked up about any particular part of your lesson. You run the risk of them ignoring you when you switch tracks and try to connect different segments of your lesson, as they continue to debate "Mustang vs. Corvette vs. Lamborghini" without hearing you talk about how the Lambo gets 6 mpg. And doesn't do well with potholes. This is an awfully fine line to straddle, though -- get 'em sufficiently hooked to listen, but not so worked up that they can't let it go. See my Michigan - Michigan state post once it finally makes it into print for more on this phenomenon.

Conclusion:

After two hours of being a real teacher, rather than a mere TF, I was exhausted, just completely and totally drained. I went home and took a nap! Plus, while now (five days later) I can at least see some successes and failures mixed together, at the time I felt dispirited, like an abject failure who crashed and burned and exploded into millions of tiny pieces. Perspective, man. It's key.

And real teachers go for twice or three times as long every day, 9 months of the year. Wow.

Thursday, November 6, 2008

Thursday, October 30, 2008

The Snickers Challenge

Some of my fondest memories of middle and high school math were the puzzles. In between memorizing algorithms and vocabulary in class, there was an occasional puzzle thrown in which I invariably found more interesting than whatever I was supposed to be learning on the lesson plan.

This is still true today; an example that comes to mind is last Thursday night (early Friday morning, really), as I lay in bed after preparing my little talk for class on Friday. I couldn't help mulling over some of the sequences of numbers I had prepared for class (this is a recurring theme for me in algebra class; I come in with 5 numbers that correspond to a pattern, and I ask the students to try to deduce the sixth). This particular day, I had the first five numbers of several sequences: the triangle numbers (1,3,6,10,15,...), the perfect squares, the cubes, the primes, and a special sequence called the "highly composite numbers" (look it up!).

I always like to try to think of different patterns the kids might see in these sequences, because there's often more than one way to get to the right answer, and I try to avoid calling any answer wrong, instead just pointing out where (usually) their perceived pattern breaks down. In this case, I knew that the triangle numbers can also be seen as the recursive sequence a_n=a_(n-1)+n, or in simpler terms you add 2, then 3, then 4, etc, running up through the positive integers. Similarly, for the squares you successively add odd integers +3, +5, +7, etc. I wondered if there was a pattern for the cubes? Well, it was 2 am but I still spent a few minutes pondering in that half-awake state trying to see what the pattern was, and I realized that

1^3 + 3 + 4 = 2^3
2^3 + 9 + 10 = 3^3
3^3 + 18 + 19 = 4^3
4^3 + 30 + 31 = 5^3
5^3 + 45 + 46 = 6^3

There's a couple of patterns here -- you could say that the first number added is 3 times the triangle numbers we just saw above, or equivalently that the first of the two sum numbers forms a pattern of +6, +9, +12, ... A deeper pattern is that the difference is 3*n^2+3*n+1, which is mathematically the difference between two successive cubes, but that's kind of cheating. There are actually more, and I think just before I fell asleep I had an even better one, but.. where was I going again? Oh, right.

The point of this tangent is that puzzles are often way more fun than what you're supposed to be learning. Especially if there is some sort of prize or at least some bragging rights for solving them. With that in mind, I created the Snickers Challenge, a collection of math puzzles for the algebra and stats classes.

Each time I go into class, I also try to create a new puzzle for the students. Sometimes, stats and algebra get the same puzzle, other times I give separate puzzles owing to the different skill sets of the classes. I usually try to present the puzzles in class, but since kids often forget the details between classes or just plain aren't paying attention, I thought a website would be a good companion to the in-class mentions, and also perhaps be a way of integrating technology into the classroom.

The website URL is mathisnofun.blogspot.com; this is purposely a tongue-in-cheek domain because I have secret ambitions of using reverse psychology on my students. The first post lays out the ground rules, but basically the first person to present a solution to a challenge gets a Snickers bar (or other candy of their choice; I had several students who were not Snickers fans). I am not above bribing students to think about math with 79 cent candybars -- so sue me.

Note to other TFs and higher-ups: I purposely created a new blogspot username for this other blog, and have not linked it in any way to the TF blogs. This is on purpose, since I would prefer the TF community of blogs to remain as private as such things can be on the internet. Since we often discuss our students, even under aliases, and since I feel it would be difficult to speak frankly about our experiences knowing that our students will read our words, I also ask that no one become a "follower" this blog, as this would also provide a link back to the TF blog community. I may link to the Snickers Challenge from this blog, but only once I make sure that leaves no trace on the receiving end of the link.

Wednesday, October 29, 2008

Three Goals

This is one of those things I should have published long ago. After talking with George, I've come up with three goals for me during my teaching fellowship:

1) Make sure students are actively involved in at least some small part of every talk. A great example of this was when I had the stats classes all flip coins for our normal distributions discussion. I also recently had students in the algebra class list their ideal careers on the blackboard and vote on which career we'd discuss in detail that day (being sure to fit in math along the way). Weaker examples of class involvement would be just asking students questions and getting them to answer, but I prefer active involvement with some sort of motion or task to be completed.

2) Get feedback from George after each class to see where he thought I was losing attention, needed to speed up / slow down, or if I missed any opportunities to work in class material.

3) Follow along in each class' textbook between visits to look for ways to relate discussions to class concepts. My best example of this was when I had the students flip coins and build bell curves just before the class talked about normal distributions.

Update / Status Overview

Apologies for the very long delay between postings. It has been over a month, which is completely unacceptable! Between running my first set of solo experiments as a grad student, trying to write my first conference paper and taking a long-planned week vacation to DC, I find I really need to catch up on my blog posts.

A brief overview first, before I go into detail on my sessions. I have just about memorized all my students' names, which makes it much more comfortable to start conversations with them, and they in turn have become much more comfortable with asking me for help with their classwork. I have given several talks to both classes by now, and have pulled out some lessons along the way which I'll share in upcoming posts. George and I have reached a good arrangement where when I talk, I take 15-20 minutes or so either at the beginning or end of the hour, with a primary goal of keeping the students engaged and inquisitive in some technical discussion, and a secondary goal of relating the discussion back to current material when possible.

Coming up next, in no particular order: my talks about primes, football & predicting the future, what we can learn from starlight, the snickers challenge, and more.